Ranking The Live Action Batman Movies From Worst To Best


Back in May I ran a feature to coincide with the release of X-Men: Days of Future Past where I ranked the X-Men movies from worst to best. As it is Batman’s 75th anniversary I wanted to run a few features to celebrate the year of the Batman, and where better to start than with the various live action films?

The idea behind the feature is pretty self-explanatory, but in case you’re wondering I will run through all eight live action Batman in the order of how good I believe them to be. If you don’t agree with my choices, you can use the comments section to tell me how wrong I am, or simply use the poll at the bottom of the list to cast your own vote.

8. Batman and Robin


Batman and Robin is the absolute nadir of the Batman franchise. I’ve spoken at length in the past about why this is such an awful film, but for those of you who haven’t already seen my reasons, here are just a few. The terrible dialogue, the neon lit Gotham, the hammy acting especially from Arnold Schwarzenegger’s Mr. Freeze, the ridiculous plot and the way the entire film feels like a huge toy commercial are just a few reasons why Batman and Robin is at the bottom of this list.

7. Batman Forever


The seeds of awfulness that grew into the form of Batman and Robin were planted here, in Batman Forever. While Batman Forever may not compare to its sequel, it was obvious to anyone watching that the Bat franchise was on a downward spiral. Val Kilmer was a better Bruce Wayne than he was a Batman, while Chris O’Donnell’s Robin came across as annoying and unnecessary. The villains didn’t fare much better either, with Tommy Lee Jones and Jim Carrey doing their best to see who can go more over the top in their scenes together. After two successful Tim Burton directed films, Batman Forever felt more like a camp Saturday morning cartoon, and we all suffered for it.

6. Batman (1966)


When watching either the Batman film from 1966 or the TV show that accompanied it, you need to take things with a serious pinch of salt. Both are known for their high levels of camp and Adam West’s Shatner esque performance of Batman. But as long as you don’t take things too seriously, and maybe have a drink or two along the way, then there’s some great fun to be had with this film. The invisible boat, the shark repellent bat spray and an exploding shark are all so over the top that it’s impossible not to enjoy this film. It also has the distinction of being the only live action Batman film to feature the Joker, Penguin, the Riddler and Catwoman all together on-screen.

5. Batman Returns


Directed by Tim Burton, Batman Returns is possibly the darkest of all the Batman movies. The movie introduced the Penguin (Danny DeVito), whose origin is even horrifying than Batman’s, and Catwoman (Michelle Pfeiffer) as the two villains who would bid to take down Michael Keaton’s Batman. Batman Returns is definitely more Burton than Batman, and his dark mind is all over this film.

4. The Dark Knight Rises


The final entry in Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy, is perhaps the weakest of his trilogy but is far from being a bad film. Two strong performances from Christian Bale and Tom Hardy anchored the film, while spirited young newcomers to the series Anne Hathaway and Joseph Gordon-Levitt gave the film a further energy. The film also had a great emotional edge that made for a great ending to an outstanding trilogy.

3. Batman Begins


The first effort to be directed by Christopher Nolan, was by his most fun effort and also the most comic book in style of his Dark Knight trilogy. The film redefined the comic book genre and kick-started a whole new generations interest in Batman.

2. Batman (1989)


Tim Burton’s Batman is one of the first films I remember seeing on VHS, and it’s a film that has stuck with me ever since. The dark imagery, the almost noir style and an iconic performance by Jack Nicholson as the Joker make this one of the most memorable films in the Batman series.

1. The Dark Knight

The Dark Knight Rises

What more can possibly be said about The Dark Knight? The film just works on so many levels. Heath Ledger’s iconic performance stands out, but there’s so much more going on here. The various themes of fear and escalation, along with terrorism and anarchy play throughout the film. While a strong cast bring out the best of the source material and make for not just one of the greatest comic book movies of all time, but also one of the greatest movies of all time in any genre.




17 thoughts on “Ranking The Live Action Batman Movies From Worst To Best

  1. great list Kieren, I think that all the Nolan one are the best tho looking objectively now. Nostalgia makes me also think the first Burton was great, but it was definitely trumped by Nolan

    1. Thanks Rob. I enjoyed writing it, so I hope you enjoyed reading it. I think Nolan’s films are probably the best as a whole but taken individually I really like the ’89 Batman.

      It could be nostalgia I guess, but I plan to watch it again soon and see.

      I’ve emailed you about taking part in film club btw. Check your spam folder, as that’s where mine sometimes end up.

  2. Very nice list, I can see where you’re coming from on them. If I were to rank them I would have DKR below Adam West, and Returns at number 2. The rest is pretty close to my own thoughts though.

    1. Thank you. It’s nice to know that there is still some love for the older entries in the series, especially the first two Burton films.

      I take it you weren’t a fan of TDKR then?

      1. It’s due for a re-watch. I enjoyed it in the theaters, but the plot holes and flaws in logic are less forgivable when it takes everything else so seriously. Also, it’s not so much that I didn’t like it, it’s just a ‘B’ or even ‘B+’ movie next to the other ‘A’s.

  3. Good list, and hard not to agree with. It’s an odd mix these Batman movies with such varying styles and approaches. I’m a big fan of Burton’s Batman Returns and think, given the chance to make it as dark as he had wanted, it would have been a masterpiece. I would have swapped it with Dark Knight Rises, which is a great film but to me, the lesser of the two. This is a fun topic to talk about.

    1. They really are such a mixed bunch of films, and when you look at the 60’s TV show and the 90’s cartoon there really are so many different approaches that have been taken towards the Batman.

  4. Hey dude, cool list and interesting opinion on all of them. For me my favourite film would be The Dark Knight Rises. Now that isn’t the most popular decision and loads of people hate TDKR, but for me regardless of the plotholes or lack of Heath Ledger, I believe the film is kick ass because it brings back the some of the comic book elements of Batman Begins and the way it connects to the first film in the trilogy is just delightful. But the main reason I like TDKR is because for the first time in film Batman has someone who he can fight one-on-one using his actual martial arts skills and he gets beaten and broken too. Plus Bane is the only villain who’s gone up against Batman and actually beat him in a fight, I loved him for that.

    1. I really liked the way it tied back into the first film as well. I also really enjoyed Tom Hardy’s Bane, and the opening scene where they hijack the plane was a superb way to open the film.

      While it may not have been as good as the first two films, it was by far from a bad film & I found it really enjoyable.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s